NJ PIP & No-Fault Car Insurance Laws: Comprehensive Victim Guide

If you’re looking for answers about how to navigate New Jersey’s car insurance laws, you’ve come to the right place. 

At Davis, Saperstein & Salomon, P.C., we know New Jersey’s auto insurance system can be confusing, especially if you haven’t gone through the process before. That’s why we’ve created this comprehensive guide to answer questions you might have after an accident and explain your rights as you seek justice and money damages for your losses. Take a look below to learn more, but don’t hesitate to contact us if you want personalized guidance and support.

Is New Jersey a no-fault state for car accidents?

Yes, New Jersey is one of a dozen states that follow a no-fault auto insurance system. Under this no-fault system, if you’re in a car accident, you and any household members in your vehicle file a claim against your own auto insurance policy for coverage of medical bills and certain other expenses, regardless of who was at fault – hence, “no fault.” The goal of New Jersey no-fault insurance is to make it easier for accident victims to get financial help after an accident without having to sue at-fault drivers. However, there are still circumstances where you could sue an at-fault driver to seek compensation for things not covered by your no-fault insurance.

What is PIP insurance in New Jersey?

PIP stands for “personal injury protection” insurance, the technical term for “no-fault” insurance. It serves as your initial coverage after an accident, regardless of who caused the crash. PIP/no-fault car insurance in NJ has two primary components:

  • Medical coverage, which pays for any treatment you receive from doctors, emergency departments, and other medical providers, as well as for necessary medical equipment, and
  • Expense coverage, which offsets a portion of your lost wages and pays for certain household expenses while you heal.

NJ personal injury protection policies come with a standard deductible of $250, although you can choose a higher amount in exchange for lower monthly premiums. There is also a standard 20 percent co-payment on the first $5,000 of medical expenses, regardless of the deductible you select.

What are New Jersey’s auto insurance requirements?

Auto insurance is mandatory in New Jersey. Every policy sold in the state must include PIP insurance that provides first-party, no-fault benefits to the purchaser. It must also include liability insurance, which pays for certain expenses not covered by PIP that other people suffer because of an accident the purchaser causes.

Consumers can choose between two types of policy:

  • Standard Policy – Provides at least $35,000 per person and $70,000 per accident in bodily injury liability. Provides at least $25,000 for property damage liability. Provides at least $15,000 in PIP coverage and up to $250,000 in PIP coverage for certain injuries. Uninsured and underinsured motorist provisions are available in the same amounts as liability coverage.
  • Basic Policy – Bodily injury liability coverage is not provided by default, but $10,000 in coverage is available as an optional add-on. Provides $5,000 per accident for property damage liability. Provides $15,000 per person, per accident in PIP coverage, and up to $250,000 for certain serious injuries, usually involving hospitalization.

How much PIP coverage should I carry in NJ?

PIP coverage in New Jersey is available in amounts as little as $15,000 per person or accident and as substantial as $250,000. The right amount for you will depend on a number of personal factors, including your income, your age, how much you drive, and your tolerance for risk. A higher policy limit can provide valuable peace of mind, but it also comes with higher monthly premiums. Conversely, lower limits can be had more affordably, but they could leave you paying out-of-pocket if you’re involved in a serious accident that requires long-term care. As attorneys, we recommend that you protect yourself and your family with $250,000 in PIP coverage.

What is the difference between “limitation on lawsuit” and “no limitation”?

Standard auto insurance policies in New Jersey can provide the purchaser with a choice between a limited and an unlimited right to sue after an accident. An unlimited policy gives you the right to sue another driver for pain and suffering as long as they are at fault for the accident. However, if you purchase the limited option, you can only sue an at-fault driver for pain and suffering if you’ve suffered a “permanent injury”, such as:

  • Loss of a body part
  • Loss of a fetus
  • Significant disfigurement or scarring
  • Permanent injury of a body part, function, or system
  • Displaced fracture
  • Death

Basic policies only have the limited right to sue option.

It’s also worth noting that the unlimited right to sue and limited right to sue options only apply to pain and suffering. PIP will still pay for your medical costs and certain other economic losses regardless of fault or which right-to-sue option you purchased.

If your collision involved a commercial vehicle, you are not subject to a threshold and have an unlimited right to sue for permanent and non-permanent injuries.

Will my PIP cover other passengers in my vehicle?

Yes, your PIP policy typically covers household members riding in the car with you, as well as other passengers who do not have coverage through another PIP policy.

Do I have to go to a specific doctor for PIP claims?

As a general rule, New Jersey’s PIP insurance system gives you the right to choose your own doctor. However, your insurer also has the right to administer Decision Point Review (DPR) and Pre-Certification for certain types of services before it will approve them as medically necessary. In other words, your healthcare provider will need to submit treatment plans and requests to perform certain tests or procedures before you receive that care. 

Having said that, depending on the terms of your policy, your insurance provider could penalize you for going outside its Voluntary Network Program (VPN) for certain services, such as durable medical equipment, diagnostic tests, medical examinations, and prescription medicines. If this happens, consider speaking with a New Jersey Personal Injury attorney.

Can I use PIP for chiropractic or physical therapy treatment?

Yes, PIP is authorized to pay for chiropractic care, physical therapy, and acupuncture.

  • Treatment must conform to the NJ Care Path, which dictates how soft tissue and spinal injuries should be treated.

Will the insurance company monitor my medical treatment?

Yes, the insurance company will monitor the medical treatment you receive. First, the insurer will want regular updates from your healthcare provider to understand your prognosis and progression. It may also perform Decision Point Reviews (DPRs) at specific intervals and before it signs off on certain tests or procedures. You can also expect a medical professional, such as a DPR nurse, to review the care you’re receiving. This case manager certifies services in accordance with your treatment plan or the NJ Care Path. If a proposed service deviates from these plans, they may suggest alternative treatment options.

Will my treatment be limited under PIP?

Your PIP insurance should cover all necessary medical care, with certain limitations imposed by:

  • Your selected PIP coverage limit, deductible, and co-payment
  • Treatments subject to pre-certification or Decision Point Review by your insurer
  • Independent medical examinations requested by the insurer
  • Your healthcare provider’s ability to make a compelling case for why certain treatment plans should be considered medically necessary
  • Restrictions on certain diagnostic tests

In short, PIP does not guarantee you unlimited treatment. However, your insurer should not arbitrarily terminate your care or refuse to sign off on medically necessary treatments. Contact a NJ car accident lawyer if you believe that you’re being denied valid care.

What if I disagree with the PIP insurer’s medical exam?

Your insurance provider will likely require you at some point to undergo an independent medical exam, or IME. An IME is an examination arranged and paid for by the insurance company and conducted by a doctor appointed by your insurance carrier to assess the current state of your accident-related injuries and whether you need additional treatment, testing, or medical equipment. The doctor conducting the IME must be someone other than your usual provider who must also practice in the same discipline as your provider. The examiner may decide to approve continued treatment, modify your provider’s plan, or deny care.

You do not have to accept the examiner’s report as final if you and your usual provider disagree with its findings. Instead, you can:

  • Request a copy of the examiner’s written report, as the law entitles you or your representative (such as an attorney) to receive it upon request
  • Have your treating doctor review the report and prepare a response supported by additional medical documentation
  • Use your insurer’s internal process to appeal its decision
  • Consider PIP arbitration if the dispute is not resolved

The insurer must notify you and your treating provider of its decision concerning further treatment no later than three business days after the examination. Contact an attorney if you need help appealing the decision.

What is “medical provider reimbursement” under PIP?

Despite what some people assume, PIP reimburses medical providers directly rather than simply cutting their insured a check to pay for their medical care. Here’s how the reimbursement process works:

  • The provider treats the accident-related injury. Any treatment the provider renders must be medically necessary and may be subject to pre-certification and Decision Point Review.
  • The provider submits the bill to the PIP carrier. The bill uses standardized procedure codes to identify the treatment rendered and includes supporting medical documentation. Medical bills must be submitted by the medical provider within 21 days of treatment commencing.
  • The insurer applies New Jersey’s PIP medical fee schedules. These schedules establish the maximum reimbursable amounts for many services based partly on the region where treatment was provided. Ordinarily, the eligible charge is either the provider’s usual, customary, and reasonable charge or the fee-schedule maximum, whichever is lower. Separate reasonableness rules apply to any services not listed on the schedule.
  • The carrier pays the approved amount directly to the provider. The payment remains subject to the patient’s PIP policy limit, a deductible, and a co-payment if those have not already been met.

What if my medical bills exceed my PIP limits?

If your medical needs exceed your New Jersey PIP limits, you may need to find other ways to pay for your care.

First, be aware that, regardless of the limits you selected when you bought your policy, your PIP may cover up to $250,000 for certain severe injuries, such as permanent or significant brain damage, or spinal cord injuries. Consult your medical provider to see if your injuries meet this threshold.

You may also be able to turn to your health insurance, including Medicare or Medicaid, for help. While PIP is generally your primary source of coverage, a health plan may provide secondary coverage for eligible expenses left over after you exhaust your PIP policy. The health plan’s own network rules, exclusions, deductible, and co-payments will apply.

An experienced New Jersey car accident lawyer can provide you with additional guidance.

How should I handle calls and communication with insurance companies after an accident?

Be aware that you have different obligations to different insurance companies. Because you signed a contract with your PIP insurer, you are likely obligated to provide it with certain information about the accident and your injuries. Be forthright, but remember that the insurer has a vested interest in paying you as little as possible.

You do not have the same responsibilities when it comes to the other driver’s insurer – and you should approach any conversations with it accordingly. Refrain from giving that insurer a recorded statement, signing a broad medical authorization, or accepting a settlement before you’ve spoken with a lawyer. You may provide basic information needed to identify the claim, but consider directing detailed questions to your attorney.

Contact Our NJ Car Accident Lawyers to Learn More

Whether you still have questions about no-fault insurance, need help pursuing pain and suffering compensation through a bodily injury claim in NJ, or simply want to protect your rights, Davis, Saperstein & Salomon, P.C. is here for you. We’ve recovered over $1 billion on behalf of more than 40,000 individuals and families, and we can put this experience and insight to work for you. Contact us today to get started with your free consultation.